Disabling Nonrequired Services (Building Internet Firewalls, 2nd Edition)

11.3. Disabling Nonrequired Services

When you have a secure machine, you can start to set up the services on it. The first step is to remove the services that you don't want to run. Consult Chapter 10, "Bastion Hosts", for more information about deciding which services you don't want to run. The main idea is to remove all services that you don't actually need for the machine to do the work it's designed to do, even if they seem convenient or harmless.

11.3.1. How Are Services Managed Under Unix?

On Unix machines, most services are managed in one of two ways:

By controlling when they start and who can use them
By service-specific configuration files

There are two ways services get started on Unix systems:

At boot time from a machine's configuration files (for example in /etc/inittab and /etc/rc files or directories)
On demand by the inetd daemon (which is itself started at boot time)

A few services -- for example, Sendmail -- can be configured to run under either or both mechanisms, but most of them strongly prefer one of the two options.

11.3.1.1. Services started by /etc/rc files or directories

Services in the first category are designed to run indefinitely. They are started once (when the machine boots), and they are never supposed to exit. (Of course, sometimes they do exit, either because they're killed by a system administrator, or because they trip over a bug or some other error.) Servers are written in this way if they need to handle small transactions quickly, or if they need to "remember" information. Writing them in this way avoids the delays associated with starting a new copy of the server to handle each request made to it.

Servers of this kind are started from a Unix system's /etc/rc files, which are shell scripts executed when the machine boots. Examples of servers typically started from /etc/rc files are those that handle NFS, SMTP, and DNS. In BSD-based versions of Unix, there are customarily a few files in /etc with names that start with "rc". (for example /etc/rc.boot). In other versions of Unix, there are customarily directories in /etc instead of files (for instance, /etc/rc0.d); the directories contain the various startup commands, each in its own little file.

In either case, you need to be careful to look at all of the startup scripts and all of the scripts they call, recursively. Usually, more than one script is run in the process of bringing a system all the way up. On modern Unix systems, those scripts often call others, sometimes through multiple levels of indirection. For example, you may find that a startup script calls another script to start up networking, and that one calls yet another script to start up file service. You may also find that startup scripts use mystical options to familiar commands (e.g., they often run ifconfig with little-used options that cause ifconfig to pick up configuration information from obscure places). Be sure that you understand these options and that you replace any that tell the machine to pick up information about itself from the network (or from services it normally provides but that you are going to turn off).

Linux and some versions of Unix have a utility called chkconfig that is used to determine whether or not services are started up. When a service is installed on a system that's using chkconfig, a startup script is also installed and always runs, but the startup script uses the chkconfig command to determine whether or not it should actually start the service. Administrators also use the chkconfig command to change or check the status of services. Different versions of the chkconfig system use different methods of storing the configuration status; some of them create files, while others store the status in the startup scripts themselves.

Some versions of Unix and Linux have a file called /etc/inittab. On these systems, the init process uses information in this file to control how the boot process is performed and to keep a number of system processes running. Normally the processes configured to be run from /etc/inittab allow interactive logins from terminal and workstation console devices. The init process will start and monitor these processes and, if configured to do so, will restart them when they terminate or die. Disabling these processes can usually be performed by commenting out the configuration line or by instructing init not to start them at all. If you change the contents of /etc/inittab, there is usually a special and operating system-dependent way to signal the init process to re-read the file.

In some versions of Unix, one of the servers that is run from the startup files is designed to restart other servers if they fail. If such a program exists on a system, it will try to start the other servers if they are removed from the startup files but not from its configuration file. Either turn off this program or be sure to remove from the program's configuration file any servers removed from the startup files. You'll notice the program when you work through the startup files.

11.3.1.2. Services started by inetd

Some servers are designed to be started "on demand" and to exit after they provide the requested service. Such servers are typically used for services that are requested infrequently, for services that aren't sensitive to delays in starting a new server from scratch, and for services that require a new server process to deal with each request (for example, Telnet or FTP sessions, where a separate server is used for each active session).

Servers of this kind are usually run from the inetd server. (The inetd server itself, because it runs indefinitely, is started from the /etc/rc files, as described in the previous section.) The inetd server listens for requests for services specified in the /etc/inetd.conf configuration file. When it hears such a request, it starts the right server to process the request.

11.3.2. Disabling Services Under Unix

As we discussed in Chapter 10, "Bastion Hosts", there are four general precautions to take when disabling services:

Make sure that you have a way to boot the machine if you disable a critical service (for instance, a secondary hard disk with a full operating system image or a bootable CD-ROM).
Save a clean copy of everything you modify so that you know how to put it back the way it was if you do something wrong.
When you disable a service, disable everything that depends on it.
Don't connect the machine you are trying to protect to a hostile network before you have completed the process of disabling services. It is possible for the machine to be compromised while you are preparing it.

Once you've set up your alternate boot process, check the startup files and directories for your system. This should be done line by line, making sure you know exactly what each line does -- including any command-line options.

In a perfect world, you would like to disable everything, and then enable only the services you need. Unfortunately, if you do this, you may find that the machine is no longer able to boot. It is slightly easier to work from the other direction by disabling services you definitely don't need, and then examining the rest of the boot process and adjusting it slowly so that the machine will always boot.

One way to start this process is to take a snapshot of all the services that are running on your machine by using the netstat utility. This utility allows you to list all of the open network connections and, with additional options, the TCP and UDP network ports that have a service configured to listen or accept datagrams. The Linux netstat utility has a very useful feature that allows you to directly list the numeric process identifier and name associated with each network port. Other versions of Unix are supplied with tools, such as fuser, which will map the network ports to the numeric process identifier. You can also use the lsof utility (see Appendix B, "Tools" for information on where to get lsof ). Once the process name is known, it can be used to search through the configuration files to find where it is started.

As mentioned before, some versions of Unix and Linux include the chkconfig program that can administratively enable and disable services. The command can be used to test whether a service is turned on, to list the services that can be controlled, and to enable or disable services. These systems work because the startup file checks to see if the service should be run. Disabling a service can be as simple as using chkconfig to turn the service off. This is a convenient and standard way to disable a service, but it doesn't leave any documentation of why the service is off, and it's very easy to re-enable a service that's been disabled this way.

Although it's more work, it's a good idea to comment out the code that starts the service or to remove the startup file altogether. This will prevent people from simply turning it back on with chkconfig, and will give you a good place to put comments about why you've disabled the service. If you do disable services with chkconfig, you should be sure to keep a list in a standard place that says what services are supposed to be disabled and why. This will help keep people from re-enabling them by mistake, and it will also allow you to easily reconfirm the list if you upgrade, patch, or reinstall software, which may change the chkconfig status of services.

On other versions of Unix, you will have no choice; you will have to comment out or delete the lines that start services you don't need. You will frequently see services that are started after a check for some configuration file. If you don't want the service to run, comment out the entire code block. Don't leave the code active simply because the configuration file doesn't currently exist and the service won't currently be started. Someone or something might create the configuration file some time in the future. Commenting out the entire thing is more secure and less risky.

Commenting out lines is preferable to removing them because it leaves evidence of your intent. When you comment something out, add a comment about why you have commented it out. If you delete something, replace it with a comment about why you have deleted it. Make sure that the next person to look at the files knows that you got rid of things on purpose and doesn't helpfully "fix" it for you. If you comment out a call to another script, add a comment in that script indicating that it's not supposed to be started and why. Renaming it or commenting out its contents are also good ways to help ensure that it won't accidentally reappear.

For every service that you leave enabled, apply the same line-by-line procedure to the service's configuration files. Obviously, you want to pay particular attention to inetd 's configuration file. On most systems, this file is called /etc/inetd.conf. (On other systems, this file might be called /etc/servers or something else; check your manual pages for inetd ). If you have a daemon-watcher and have decided to leave it on, its configuration files are also particularly important.

This process will need to be repeated if you install new software or a patch, because sometimes the startup scripts are modified or replaced. Installation scripts often assume that you will want to run all the software you are installing, and will helpfully turn it on for you, in its default, insecure configuration, even when you are upgrading an old installation on which it was turned off. You will want to have good documentation about your desired configuration to refer to when you install upgrades, patches, or new software. In any case, you should certainly disconnect the system from any hostile networks before performing any software installation or patching.

11.3.3. Which Services Should You Leave Enabled?

Certain services are essential to the operation of the machine, and you'll probably need to leave these enabled, no matter what else the machine is configured to do. On a Unix system, these processes include:

init, swap, and page

In addition, you'll obviously need server processes for the services that you've decided to provide on your bastion host (e.g., real or proxy Telnet, FTP, SMTP, and DNS servers). You will also need servers for any protocols you intend to use for remote administration of the machine (usually, sshd).

You should audit the configuration files for the services you leave enabled, to be sure that they are configured appropriately. The manual page for a service is a good place to find out which configuration files are used. In the preceding list, we have already discussed the configuration files for syslogd and inetd. Checking the configuration files for the cron service is frequently overlooked. Vendors typically provide a number of housekeeping functions that are not suitable for a bastion host. In particular, you should check for places where the system log files are rotated. You will typically find that cron will attempt to rotate log files on a weekly basis and may discard information older than two weeks. We suggest that you check these housekeeping rules and bring them into alignment with your policy on how long to keep log files.

ypserv
ypbind
ypupdated

These servers are generally started at boot time from the /etc/rc files.

Also disable these RPC-based services:

rexd (the remote execution service, started by inetd )
walld (the "write all", or wall daemon, started by inetd )

All RPC-based services depend on a single service usually called portmap (on some machines it is known as rpcbind ). If you've disabled all of the RPC-based services, you can (and should) also disable the portmap service. How can you tell if you've disabled all the RPC-based services? Before disabling portmap, but after disabling what you think are the rest of the RPC-based services, reboot the machine and then issue a rpcinfo -p command. If the output of that command shows only entries for portmap itself, this means that no other RPC services are running. On the other hand, if the output shows that other RPC services are still running, you will need to investigate further to determine what and why. If you decide to provide any RPC-based services, you must also provide the portmap service. In that case, consider using Wietse Venema's replacement portmap, which is more secure than the versions shipped with most Unix systems (see Appendix B, "Tools" for information on where to find it).

11.3.4.3. Booting services

Your bastion host should probably not provide booting services; nothing should trust the host enough to be willing to boot from it. This means that, in most cases, you should disable these services:

tftpd
bootd
bootpd
dhcpd

11.3.4.4. BSD "r" command services

These should all be disabled. The servers for these services are typically named rshd, rlogind, and rexecd and are typically started by inetd. The remaining "r" services are based on them and will not run without them.

11.3.4.5. routed

Another server that your bastion host probably doesn't need is routed. This server is started at boot time from the /etc/rc files, listens to routing information broadcasts, and updates the kernel routing table based on what it hears.

You probably don't need routed on your bastion host because your bastion host is probably located on the perimeter of your network, where routing should be fairly simple. A more secure approach is to create static routes pointing to your internal networks and a default route pointing to your Internet gateway router. You do this at boot time by adding appropriate "route add" commands to the /etc/rc files.

If you must do dynamic routing on your bastion host, obtain and use a routing daemon that will provide some sort of authentication on the source of routing information. Either it should filter routes based on their source address, or it should support an authenticated routing protocol like RIP v2. If you want to use an authenticated routing protocol, be sure that your routers also support it; if you want to filter on source address, be sure to actually configure the daemon to do so. Traditionally, the most popular routing daemon of this type has been GateD, but others are now available, including Zebra. Appendix B, "Tools", has information on how to get these daemons.

11.3.4.6. fingerd

The finger server supplies information about existing accounts and accounts on Unix systems. This server is started on demand by inetd. The information provided by fingerd can be valuable to attackers; it tells them information about potential targets, such as:

Which accounts exist

This tells them which accounts they should try to guess passwords for.

Personal information about the people with accounts

This tells them what passwords to start guessing with.

Which accounts are in use

This tells them which accounts should be avoided, at least until they're not in use.

Which accounts haven't been used lately

This tells them which accounts are good targets for attack because the owners probably won't notice that the accounts are being used.

On the other hand, Internet users often use finger (the program that talks to your fingerd daemon) quite legitimately. finger is helpful in locating email addresses and telephone numbers. Instead of simply disabling fingerd, you might want to replace it with a program that obtains information from a more basic source of contact information for your site; the information might include:

Your main phone number
Who to contact if they have questions about your site's products or services
Sample email addresses if standardized aliases such as Firstname_Lastname are maintained for users at your site
Who to contact in case of network or security problems involving your site

You can provide this kind of generic information to anybody who uses finger to check on your site, regardless of what specific information they've requested. The easiest way to accomplish this is to put the information in a file (for example, /etc/finger_info) and then replace the part of the /etc/inetd.conf entry for fingerd that specifies the program to run with something like /bin/cat /etc/finger_info. Doing this causes the contents of the /etc/finger_info file to be returned to anyone contacting your fingerd server.

For example, here is the old /etc/inetd.conf line from Great Circle Associate's system:

finger stream tcp nowait nobody /usr/libexec/fingerd fingerd

and here is the new /etc/inetd.conf line:

finger stream tcp nowait nobody /bin/cat cat /etc/finger_info

and here are the contents of the /etc/finger_info file:

Great Circle Associates 
Phone: +1 415 555 0841 
Email: [email protected] 
 
For more information, or to report system problems, please  
send email or call.

11.3.4.7. ftpd

If you're going to provide anonymous FTP service on your bastion host, you need to reconfigure the FTP server appropriately. You should replace the ftpd program with one more suited to providing anonymous FTP service than the standard ftpd programs shipped by most Unix vendors. (See Chapter 17, "File Transfer, File Sharing, and Printing", for information about providing anonymous FTP service.)

If you're not going to provide anonymous FTP, you can probably disable your FTP server entirely; it's started on demand by inetd.

Even if you've disabled the FTP server on your bastion host, you can still use the FTP client program (typically called simply ftp) on the bastion host to transfer files to and from other systems. You'll just have to do the work from the bastion host, instead of from the other systems.

11.3.4.8. Other services

There are lots of other services you probably don't need and should disable. Although the specific list depends on your own site's security policy and needs, and on the platform you're using, it should probably include the following:

uucpd

UUCP over TCP/IP

rwhod

Sort of like fingerd, in that it tells you who's currently logged in on the system

lpd

The BSD printer daemon or other printing services

11.3.5. Running Services on Specific Networks

In some cases, you want to run some services that need to respond to only one network on a machine with multiple network interfaces. You may be able to limit those services to just the networks you wish to use them on. Under Unix, this usually means specifying which IP addresses and/or network interfaces you want the service to respond to as part of the service's startup options; this will be slightly different for every service, and not all services provide this facility.

11.3.6. Turning Off Routing

As we discussed in Chapter 10, "Bastion Hosts", most machines with more than one network interface will automatically attempt to route traffic between interfaces. You do not normally want a bastion host to do this. If you are not trying to configure a bastion host that is also a router, you should turn off routing, which is a three-part process:

Turn off services that advertise the system as a router.
Turn off IP forwarding, which actually does the routing.
If necessary, turn off source routing separately.

We discussed turning off routing services in Chapter 10, "Bastion Hosts". If you have decided to leave these services running (perhaps you are running routed or GateD because the bastion host is in a complex and changeable routing environment), you will need to explicitly configure these services not to advertise the machine as a router.

You will also need to turn off IP forwarding. Turning off routing services merely keeps the machine from advertising itself as a router; it doesn't keep the machine from routing packets. Preventing the machine from routing packets requires modifications to the kernel. Fortunately, these days most Unix vendors provide supported parameters for turning off IP forwarding. Even for vendors that don't, it's about as easy as kernel patches get on most machines: turning off IP forwarding requires a change in the value of only a single kernel variable. You need to consult your vendor to find out how to turn off IP forwarding on your machines.

On some machines, turning off normal IP forwarding will not also turn off source routing; it will still be possible for an attacker to get packets through the machine. (Source routing is discussed further in Chapter 10, "Bastion Hosts".) If you are not screening out all source routed packets before they reach the bastion host, you should consult your vendor to find out how to disable source routing in addition to normal IP forwarding.


11.2. Securing Unix		11.4. Installing and Modifying Services